Welcome to DeMara's Italian Restaurant
DeMara's Italian Restaurant, located at 2070 Peach Orchard Rd in Sumter, SC, is a cherished gem known for its warm, family-friendly atmosphere and delectable offerings. Diners rave about the rich flavors of the meatballs and the generous toppings on their famous subs and pizzas. Many loyal customers, like Sandra from Latta, travel hours for a taste of the delightful cuisine. Whether savoring a perfectly crafted salad or indulging in creamy macaroni and cheese, each dish embodies a dedication to quality and comfort. With a commitment to service, DeMara's is not just a restaurant; it’s a beloved gathering place for food lovers.
DeMara's Italian Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings
This was my first time coming here and everything was delicious. The ppl was very friendly and informative. I pass by the place all the time and i thought it was closed down. Its a nice little family own restaurant. I will be returning.
I drive from Latta SC, just to eat here. The meatballs are the most delicious you can find! Food is amazing! Prices are amazing! The People are the Best!!!!!
Went here while on a business trip and ordered a salad. It was so good I went back a couple days later and got one of their subs; it was also excellent. Highly recommend for a good quick bite.
I come here to get the best subs and the most toppings on the pizzas they sell. I hone learned about this place through my dad and haven’t forgotten about them since. You can call your order in and they bring your food out to you no extra charge and its gonna be hot and ready.
The best pizza in Sumter, hands down. And the Macaroni and cheese is to die for!!!! Tonight wasn't as good as it has been in the past. The pizza crust wasn't cooked all the way through and it seems like my order was given to someone else, because my family ordered a other pizza and macaroni and cheese after I did and they received there order 10 minutes before I got mine. It wasn't the best night for me.
I think that tomorrow is Italian restaurant has great pizza to me. It is a lot better than any fast food chain like Domino’s or Papa John’s. It’s just so different and good and delicious so if you were out for the night and her were thinking someplace to go to dinner check out Demar’s Italian restaurant You will not be disappointed, dine in or takeout either way you’ll love it!!
First time back inside this restaurant in 40 years....looks nice inside with an outside eating area
Best Pizza around, been open for years and years. A staple restaurant to the community. Family friendly and everyone knows everyone there. Highly recommend if in the area.
Location
-
2070 Peach Orchard Rd, Sumter, SC 29154, United States Hotline: +1 803-499-4741
Welcome to DeMara's Italian Restaurant, a charming and authentic Italian culinary haven nestled in Sumter, SC. Located at 2070 Peach Orchard Rd, this lovely family-owned eatery invites you to indulge in a delightful array of Italian classics that are not just meals, but true experiences.
As you step inside, the warm ambiance and friendly staff immediately make you feel at home. Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere, creating a sense of community that enhances every visit. Whether you're a local or just passing through, like many of its loyal patrons, you will find yourself returning time and again. As Nicole notes in her first-time visit, “The people were very friendly and informative,” highlighting the care and attention you can expect.
At the heart of DeMara's menu lies an array of scrumptious dishes that reflect the essence of Italian comfort food. Don’t miss out on their renowned meatballs, which Sandra Moss claims are “the most delicious you can find,” reflecting the restaurant's commitment to using quality ingredients and authentic recipes. The combination of hearty meatballs served with a side of pasta or in a sub is satiating, making for a meal that feels like a warm hug on a plate.
From fresh salads that turn a simple dish into a flavorful experience to their beloved subs and pizzas, every bite is crafted with care. Rello Dmv praises the many toppings and options available, perfect for customizing your pizza just the way you like it. The variety and quality are evident, appealing to both casual diners and Italian food lovers alike.
However, like any gem in the culinary world, there may be off days. Derek Wilson shares his mixed experience, reminding us that even the best restaurants can have moments where service or food quality may fluctuate. But overall, the rave reviews far outweigh the occasional hiccup, with many returning for the outstanding macaroni and cheese or the signature pizzas that have earned the title “best pizza in Sumter.”
In essence, DeMara's Italian Restaurant is not merely a place to eat. It’s a space where flavors intertwine with hospitality, creating memories in every meal. Whether for a casual lunch, a family dinner, or a quick bite on a busy day, DeMara's delivers delicious, comforting food that keeps you coming back for more.
So, if you’re in the area, make sure to visit DeMara's Italian Restaurant. You’ll undoubtedly leave with a satisfied palate and a desire to return.